Bill Anderson delivered interesting news on the craft industry's
investment outlook at Monday's Brewbound conference.
LOTS OF CASH CHASING A UNIQUE CULTURE. Bill explained how there
is "no shortage of investors who want into the craft arena."
His group has met recently with three large family offices in
New York that want into the space, and an international company
that wants to make a large craft investment. The draw is "fun,
iconic" brands affecting not just beer or the beverage space, but
also culture and consumerism in general.
"But they're also doing the math, saying, 'If craft is
5% of volume and 7% of dollars of a $95 billion U.S. beer market,
and people are saying it could be ... 10% or 20%, or [as Steve
Hindy recently said of full-flavored, high margin beer's potential]
30%, you're talking about $15 to $20 or more billion
worth of money at play. That's what's attracting private
equity." He estimates that First Beverage hears from private
equity firms "once or twice a week" asking for introductions to the
craft space.
"Usually we don't say yes. I think there's a huge culture
question of private equity coming into the craft beer space," says
Bill. And he has other concerns.
MISMATCHED EXPECTATIONS AND CULTURES. Investors may see craft's
rosy picture and growth numbers, and the way craft's influence
extends. And they may be crunching those aforementioned potentials.
And hoping to fund the next New Belgium.
In reality, the cultures have potential to clash. Bill isn't
confident, for example, that some outfits understand the "costs of
iconic, socially responsible brand resonance" that is craft's
bottled lightening. Moreover, he doesn't know if they have the
patience it takes to get brands "lifted," citing the phenomenon of
Blue Moon's 15-year "overnight success."
Investors also don't like high capital expenditures. "Private
equity doesn't like to see a lot of money going into brewing
facilities," Bill says. But Schlafly's Dan Kopman and Saint Arnold
head and former banker Brock Wagner estimate it will take some $1.5
billion to build the capacity needed to take craft to 10 share.
Finally, they'd have to come to alignment on exit strategies,
over which the segment itself is struggling. It's also struggling
on whether it wants to take private equity money to begin with.